Wednesday, November 12, 2014

Belcher the Progressive: "Liberty & Authenticity"



Our beloved 18th century reenacting hobby suffers from regular eruptions of vitriol and resentment over standards or authenticity, enflamed by  our values-laden perceptions of those whose impressions and motivations range from scrupulous adherence to surviving documentation to simply having a nice weekend outdoors in funny clothes.  I tend toward the "authenticity conscious" or "progressive" end of the continuum, tempered by the knowledge that documentation is limited and hypotheses are meant to be tested.  Also, a good sense of humor has gotten me out of tight spots on more than one occasion in this hobby, most notably the ill-advised “sausages of the Crown” incident of 2011 that launched a score of broadsheets, inspired a ballad and birthed a legend.
With that in mind, I am delighted to discover that Constant Belcher was himself, for brief a time at least, a "progressive" soldier in the 18th century.  In late 1774, when  Committees of Observation, Inspection, Correspondence and Safety were busy setting up shadow governments across the Colonies, while local trained bands drilled among the livestock on the Commons of New England, one company of Essex County militia in East Jersey appears to have decided to get into the act by going back to its roots.  In this, the earliest known entry in the Belcher Journal yet to have come to light, we discover the pains to which these patriots were willing to go for the sake of Liberty and Authenticity.




“Dec 13th [1774]  Thair be sum Gen’lmen of This Town afixin’ to re-ereate a Coy of Milisha in ye Manner of our Olde Jarzey Provincial Regt. from ye French War / As Father did Serve at Sabati Poont in ’57 wair ye Heathen did relief him his Topnot did think it proper to ‘List to remember his Sacrifice. 



Dec 14th
To Day did attend ye Committee of Reenaction at Williamson’s Hogshead [Tavern] with a mind to jine ye new Provo Coy /  Much debate concerning what Impression to make, de Hart does favour  ’62 when the Blues got Yellowjack in Habana whilst Mayor [Ephraim] Tyrell spoke for ’57 when the Regt. was well scupper’ d in thair Batoos / As few old soldjers did survive these Campaigns but little Material culture does remain to inform Authentick uniforms  &etc. For my part Father did leave me naught but his Hoern as patrimony graven “Fools Such as We”/ Did offer this Relick to Committee for Inspection, directly they did attest its documentation for ye True Motto to be blazon’d upon  ye Colours.


Dec 15th   Ye Committee still debilitates ye Standards of Authenticity for ye Provo Coy/ Dr. Barnett did Procure certain Papers from ye Provincial Assembly from ’58 as did authorize short uniform coats “after the Highland Manner” /  Grate disputation re: such  Garmints as naught in our Number is of Scottish Descant tho’ sum are of Presbyterian stock / Subcommittee of Observation sent with dispatch to Nieu Yorck with divers Articles of a drafty nature to render from Life ye Trews & Coatees of any Highland Regt to be found among ye Ministerial Forces thair.

Dec 18th  This Day did hear of a fine Portrait of Colo. Shirley in ye old Regimental of the Jarzy Provos at Spanktown & did travel thair as a Body to Authenticate / ‘Tis a faire likeness in Oyl of ye Olde Blue Uniform of madder Facd/  ye Skirts are over long for ’58 & ye Waste Coat too fine for Common use / Ye Coy mooted viz: yellow buttons Gas back or no / Returnd this Even. To Williamson’s to drink on it more.


Dec 29th
– Still no Resolution, ye Committee makes no progression on ye Provo impression / Word has come from Phila.  of the Provincial resolves forNon Importation from Britain, Most distressing to Our Cause as ‘twill deprive us of ye proper K&P Broadcloth needed to clothe the Coy in Authentic Fashion.
Dec 3oth  Drilld  To day in the olde manner/ Did Find it Bland.

Jan 2nd [1776] –  Treason of ye Blackest dye!  This Day Capt. Woodruff  did revile a disaffected person in our Coy who did contrary to Gen’l orders of ’58 refuse to cut down his Round Hat with Yellow tape for to go a-Campaigning, also did fashion Indian leggings of Brown broadcloth in place of Blue or Green as establishd in ye Documentation for our Impression.

Jan 6th Took French Leave of the Re-created Jarzy Provo Coy, much fatigud by Research,  Have determin’d Soldjerin' must be ye proper Province of Scholars, not fools such as we."


Wednesday, October 29, 2014

Alive, Alive, Oh No: Belcher and Matters of Precendence in the Factious 1st NJ

The Battle of Springfield New Jersey (June 23rd, 1780) was the last, large land engagement in the Middle States during the American Revolution.  A Crown force of more than 5,000 troops from the New York garrison under Hessian Lieut. General Wilhelm von Knyphausen, crossed from Staten Island on the night of June 6-7 and was held at Connecticut Farms by determined Jersymen in Maxwell's Brigade and local militia coordinated by Maxwell's A.D.C and former Brigade Major Aaron Ogden.  Pushing on toward Morristown, Knyphausen's columns were recalled when a staff officer arrived from Sir Henry Clinton, who was on his way northward from his successful operations in the South with a plan of his own that this unauthorized raid threatened to upset.  Leaving the village a smoking ruin (and the body of the parson's wife and distant Ogden relation Hannah Caldwell lying dead in the street), the invading troops withdrew the following evening to occupy Elizabethtown.  During the next weeks British reinforcements arrived by sea while Washington's army awaited developments from its refuge in the Watchung mountains, and the Jersey Brigade occupied forward positions below. 

Two roads led from Elizabethtown West toward Springfield and Hobart Gap, which was the key to reaching the Continental Army encampment at Morrisotwn. Knyphausen's force, now with Clinton's blessing, advanced along both of these during the Battle of Springfield in an attempt on Hobart Pass. Along the Galloping Hill Rd., Col. Israel Angell's 2nd Rhode Island Regiment defended the first bridge over the Rahway River, with Col. Israel Shreve's 2nd NJ in support along with Proctor's Artillery.  The bridge on the Vauxhall Rd. was defended by about 50 dragoons from the 2nd Partisan Corps under Major Henry "Lighthorse" Lee, supported by Col. Matthias Ogden's 1st NJ and some local militia. As it happened, the position was outflanked the day of the Battle by the Queen's Rangers and NJ Volunteers (loyalists), and Lee was compelled to execute a fighting retreat.


It is interesting to note that it was Major Lee, and not Col. Matthias Ogden, who had command of the Continental forces in this sector.  There is strong evidence, though, that Col. Ogden was indisposed and unable to take the field.  In closing a letter to their father dated June 15th, 1780 (published in Wheeler's Ogden Family genealogy) in which he describes the fight at Connecticut Farms, the Colonel's brother Maj. Aaron Ogden notes: "Colo. Ogden has been ill, but is now fast recovering."


The 1st NJ was also without another of its senior officers, Major Daniel Piatt, who had died of disease at Jockey Hollow in Morristown on April 16th, 1780 and had not yet been replaced.  Not only that, but its Lieutenant Colonel, David Brearley had retired the previous August and was now New Jersey's Chief Justice.  One of Ogden's former captains, Major John Conway, (having served in the meantime as Major in the 4th and then 3rd NJ), had been promoted on August 23rd, 1779 by Major General Sullivan during the campaign against the Iroquois to fill Brearley's vacancy as Lt. Colonel.   Lt. Col. Conway would have been senior to Major Lee, and by the rules of precedence should have been in command of the force at Vauxhall Rd.  Bridge if he were available to serve, but his appointment by Sullivan was not confirmed by the State of New Jersey until March 17th, 1780.  His ultimate status as Lt. Colonel was not clearly resolved until Washington himself included a report to that effect in a communication on July 4th, 1780 with General Greene: nearly two weeks after the Battle of Springfield.


Conway was no friend of Col. Ogden's, having given evidence at Court Martial against the Colonel in 1779, after having been brought up himself on court martial charges by the Colonel just three months before.  Perhaps he delayed what would not have been a pleasant reunion, or perhaps the uncertain status of his appointment kept him away from the army altogether until after Washington's letter to Greene.  He and Colonel Ogden managed not to serve together during the remainder of 1780, with Ogden on command with 4 light companies in Lafayette's Light Division in early August leaving rest of the regiment under Conway.


Until now the best that historians could do was to speculate as to the reason it was Lee and not Conway had command at Vauxhall Rd. Bridge.  A close reading of a recently deciphered fragment from the Belcher Journal, however, opens yet another possibility that would account both for Conway's absence and for Colonel Ogden's prolonged illness that kept him on the sidelines.  Once again, as an example of the "small man" theory of historical contingency, Constant Belcher plays a singular, if unwitting role the developments.



"June 3rd[1780] - Engagd To Day a-waiting table for Scotch Willie [Brig. Gen William Maxwell]'s Jazry Officrs / Col. Shreve [of the 2nd NJ] now near 23 stone & large as a Knox /   Maj. Roz [Brigade Major John Ross, of the 2nd NJ] & Majr. Ogden [Captain Aaron Ogden of the 1st NJ, Maxwell's A.D.C. and former Brigade-Major] ingrate agitation how to be sittin' sich Gent'lmen as have we by Senority. 

Colo. Ogden
[Matthias Ogden of the 1st NJ] cannot abide Colo.De Hart [Lt. Colonel William De Hart of the 2nd NJ, formerly of the 1st] nor Colo. Conway [Lt. Col. John Conway of the 1st NJ, formerly of the 1st, 4th and 3rd NJ] since ye courts martial / Colo. Dayton [Elias Dayton of the 3rd NJ) and Colo. Spencer [Oliver Spencer, of Spencer's Additional Continental Regiment] are Colo. Ogden's father-in-low & bother-in-lieu & of his faction / Col Barber [Lt. Colonel Francis Barber of the 3rd NJ, Assistant Inspector-General]wuz marid to por Cozin Mary [Ogden, sister of Matthias and Aaron], now diseasd / A fine Mess thay make of it Sartin ye Claret shall be aflowin' along wid ye port if thair wuz no Neutral Ground to be found at dinar. 

Colo. Shreve did present a bushel of Barnegat Arsters as a Peas Offalling, tho not in brine as any Bayman worth his salt would know but fresh
took of a Month with no Ar & unfit for humane consumshun.  Thair was no time to warn Colo. Ogden before he did set to, but saw no harm in letting Colo. Conway eat his fill before enforming Mag. Ogden of that West Jarzy natural [Shreve]'s foe pass as ye Froglanders say.  Both orificers did directly trot to ye sinks & so to bed agrownin'.  As we have no Majr fit for to Command ye Battal'n, Capt. Forman [John Forman, eldest Captain of the 1st NJ] may serve.  Prey our neighburs ye British be Snugg enuf in Niew Yorck town & Staaten Eland whilst our Colo. does remain dishabille.